← From The Remnant

The Remnant News · Article

On Conspiracy Theories

A Christian perspective.


When you read “conspiracy theory” you might immediately be taken back to disputed details surrounding JFK’s assassination, the moon landing, 9/11, and other significant events in America’s history. However, conspiracy theories have been around for millennia. It’s not something that started in the 1960s, 2001, or in the past few election cycles in America, nor is it confined to one particular political ideology. Conspiracy theories run amuck on both the left and the right, politically and figuratively.

Given this, I figured this would be a topic worthwhile to think through and write about Christianly.

The Problem With Conspiracy Theories

What is a conspiracy theory? A belief or explanation that suggests that events or situations are the result of a secret, often sinister, plan by powerful people or groups.

I take issue with so many conspiracy theories because it goes against much of a biblical worldview. Often times, conspiracy theorists put forth a claim that:

1) Is unfalsifiable and claims that we can never know, or
2) Contradicts the truth in the face of facts, or
3) Asserts that truth is fungible

The Examples Cut Both Ways

A recent poll released by Morning Consult found one in three registered Democrats believe it is "credible" that the assassination attempt in Butler, Pa., was staged and not intended to kill Trump. The left has a pervasive “BlueAnon” problem.

Not to be outdone, we also saw swaths of assertions swirling around social media that President Biden had died in the summer. Questions and claims were made surrounding how he died, how long he had been dead, and who was responsible for his death. “Where is Joe?” was trending on X and speculation caught like a wildfire. And yet, he came out of the woodwork within a couple days after a recent bout of COVID. Was this a conspiracy theory? Yes, just like the one mentioned above. And even worse, they’re falsehoods.

There were many more in 2020 that turned out to be false. There was no tracker in the vaccine. While fear-mongering was an ever-present tactic, it wasn’t a “fake virus.” Due to goldfish-like attention spans, we often forget that Kamala Harris publicly cast doubt on the vaccine’s integrity so long as Trump recommended that Americans should get the jab. At some point the left and the right switched positions and the only thing in congruence was that we declared whatever came out of our own mouths was the right position to take.

So what do we do with theories that were initially derided as “conspiracy theories,” but turned out to be true? There are certainly those that fit this bill. Given the connotation of falsehood with “conspiracy theories,” I believe it’s best to label conspiracy theories that turned out to be proven true as “alternative theories.”

How Did We Get Here?

I believe alternative theories can be correct and they can be helpful. We’re commanded to be “innocent as doves and shrewd as serpents” (Matthew 10:16). When Jesus says we are to be sheep, it is unto the Good Shepherd, not the wolves of the world (John 10:11, Matthew 7:15).

Conspiracy theories and alternative theories make sense of the world around us. In fact, conspiracy theories only make sense in a post-Genesis 3 world.

  1. It is a result of the fall

    1. Prior to Adam’s sin, we had a properly ordered world (Genesis 1:31). Adam and Eve ruled on behalf of God’s authority over everything. Everything had its rightful place — including ideas.

  2. It is in response to the fall

    1. We not only have a truth crisis, we have a trust crisis. The world we inhabit is riddled with sin, both in and around us. The doctrine of “original sin” is, as my dad says, “immediately obvious to the most casual observer.” There have been coverups. In and outside of the church, there are people in positions of influence that misuse and abuse their power. Christians understand that humanity is born into a sinful nature (Psalm 51:5), the heart is deceitful above all things (Romans 5:12), and that even regenerate Christians must follow the Lord’s wisdom above their own inclinations (Proverbs 3:5-6).

What I fear for those who have given in to each and every conspiracy theory (or just the ones that their closest “in-groups” affirm) is that there has been an overarching theory that has taken root in their hearts and minds— truth is unknowable or fungible. And it is rotting them to the core.

What is Truth?

First, let’s address the overarching theory. There is such a thing as truth or “fixed realities.” Factually, it is true that humans need oxygen to live. Morally, it is true that it is always wrong to intentionally kill an innocent human being. According to Newton's Third Law of Motion, for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. There are Truths that are true for all people, all cultures, all places, and all times.

Is the Truth Knowable?

Yes, truth is indeed knowable.

We live in an age of epistemological crisis. We don’t know if we can know anything for certain anymore. The air we breathe is skepticism and the spirit of our age wars against historicity, tradition, authority, and anything religion. It’s almost as if our struggle isn’t merely against “flesh and blood” and we face “rulers, authorities, powers of this dark world, and spiritual forces of evil” in our midst (Ephesians 6:12).

This truth crisis extends beyond political conspiracy theories, but even into ontological conspiracy theories — what it means to be a man or a woman, a boy or a girl. We have journals, universities, the medical establishment, mainstream media, and nearly half of our politicians who continue to intentionally confuse some of the most vulnerable among us regarding their God-ordained sex and gender.

They contend that there is no “the truth,” there is only “your truth.” While Oprah Winfrey’s live audience received free goodie bags during their attendance, multiples more have been given a load they were not meant to bear, a mission they can never achieve, a destination at which they will never arrive.

Think Christianly

A Christian may explore alternative theories contrasted with what is presented, but only in pursuit of a higher good than the theory itself, namely truth. One of the destructive tendencies that accompanies conspiracy theories is it often holds something other than truth in its place. If a theory is in pursuit of the truth, then it is always a good. Just as long as you can arrive at The Destination.

We worship the one, true God (Jeremiah 10:10, John 17:3, 1 John 5:20). Believers are instructed in how to worship God truly (Romans 12:1-2). All throughout Scripture, God places a painfully obvious priority on truth.

I think C.S. Lewis said it best in The Abolition of Man: “You cannot go on seeing through things for ever. The whole point of seeing through something is to see something through it... If you see through everything, then everything is transparent. But a wholly transparent world is an invisible world. It is good that the window should be transparent, because the street or garden beyond it is opaque. How if you saw through the garden too? It is no use trying to ‘see through’ first principles. If you see through everything, then everything is transparent. But a wholly transparent world is an invisible world. To ‘see through’ all things is the same as not to see.”

“Seeing through things” must be a means to a greater end, and not the end itself. If you place the cart before the horse, you will find yourself in a situation much like the man living in a house that was built on sand (Matthew 7:24-27).

We must cling to the promises of God (2 Peter 1:4). Truth is not only knowable, but it will set us free (John 8:32). As Paul wrote, “For it is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery” (Galatians 5:1). Do not be like the fool who refuses to delight in understanding (Proverbs 18:2). Christ has given us the ability to know the truth. And even better, Christ has given us Himself, the Truth (John 14:6). Thanks be to God that we too can say, like the old hymnist, “I once was blind, but now I see.”